Volume 28, Issue 6: December, 2001

Abstract

RECONCILING CONCEPT AND CONTEXT: THE DILEMMA OF IMPLEMENTATION IN SCHOOL-BASED HEALTH PROMOTION

Marjorie A. MacDonald, PhD, RN and Lawrence W. Green, DrPH

The researchers used grounded theory methodology to study the implementation of a school-based alcohol and drug prevention project in secondary schools in British Columbia, Canada. Prevention workers (PWs) were responsible for working with school and community personnel in a collaborative process to develop, implement, and evaluate prevention strategies in the school using an adaptation of the Precede-Proceed Model for health promotion planning. Before they could begin to do this, PWs had to establish their credibility in the school. Once accepted, the focus of the PWs' work was to reconcile the goals, values, and philosophy of the project with those of the school. In doing so, PWs encountered many practical dilemmas. The challenges in resolving these dilemmas are presented, and the implications for policy and practice are discussed.