From McIlvainea 14(1):93-98, 1999

1998 ANNUAL REPORT OF THE
NORTH AMERICAN MYCOLOGICAL ASSOCIATION'S
MUSHROOM POISONING CASE REGISTRY

Kenneth W. Cochran*
Toxicology Committee, North American Mycological Association
*3556 Oakwood, Ann Arbor, MI 48104-5213; kwcee@umich.edu

    For 1998 the Registry received 64 reports involving 56 human cases (38 adults, 18 children) and 8 animals (7 dogs, 1 cat). This represents a decrease from the 141 reports received for 1997.A single fatality involved a dog eating Amanita virosa.

Demographics.

    The locations of the 1998 cases and the sources of reports are shown in Table 1. Reporting is voluntary and participation is spotty, and the results probably represent more the reporting of mushroom poisoning than the actual and unknown occurrence of incidents.
Table 1
Locations of Cases and Sources of Reports
State/Province Patient 
Location
Reporter 
Location
Alaska 5 3
Colorado 28 44
Idaho 10 0
Minnesota 2 2
Montana 2 1
Nevada 2 0
New Hampshire 1 1
New Jersey 5 5
New York 2 1
North Dakota 1 1
Oregon  6 6

    For the human cases reported for 1998 of the 38 adults, 23 were male, 14 female, 1 gender not reported; male to female ratio, 1.6. For the children, 15 years or younger 10 were male, 7 female, 1 gender not reported; M/F, 1.4. For comparison for all cases through 1998, the M/F ratios were 1.6 for adults; 1.2 for children. Age distribution is shown in Table 2.

Table 2
Age Distribution of Human Cases

 
1998
1983-98
Age (yrs.)
#
%*
#
%*
<1 1 2 1 0.1
1-5 10 21 167 18
6-10 2 4 40 4
11-15 4 8 39 4
16-25 5 10 161 18
26-50 18 38 298 37
51-65 7 15 133 15
>65 0 0 74 8
Child-unspecified 1*   114*  
Adult-unspecified 8*   592*  
Unknown 0   2*  
Total 47* 98@ 913* 104@
*Percentages calculated from the reported    @ Rounding error

    For 1998 the median age for children was 2.5 years, for adults, 37.5. For 13 children 9 years or younger, all were accidental exposures to raw mushrooms- "grazers.". Eight children, 3 years and younger were all asymptomatic, with the exception of one 2-year-old who ingested an Agaricus possibly xanthodermus complex. Older grazing children, ages 5-9, experienced symptoms. One 11-year-old, part of a family, was ill from eating Amanita muscaria, misidentified as puffballs. Three 15-year olds were part of a cluster of 7, ages 15-23, ingesting mushrooms for recreation. Five other recreational users were ages 31-35; one, 57. Most adults ingested mushrooms as food, cooked; but 10% ate the mushrooms raw, 5% mixed raw and cooked; 10% preparation unreported. Alcohol use was reported in 24% of the cases.

    In comparison to the reports for 1983-98, the median age for children with reported ages was 4 years; for adults, 40. Use as food accounted for 72% of the cases; of whom 75% cooked their mushrooms; 19% ate them raw; 7% unknown, mixed, pickled or dried. Alcohol use was reported in 22% of the cases. Recreational ingesters, less than 1%, ranged from 6 to 57 years, median 19, omitting one 2-year-old given "a swallow or two" of a pyschodelic mushroom tea.

Mushrooms

    The 21 species of mushrooms for which species attribution was good or probable are listed in Table 3. The species identifications are those of the reporters, and the list is limited to cases where the species attribution was certain or probable.

Table 3
Species Reported in 1998

Species 1998 Cases Location Prior Cases
Amanita muscaria 9 CO, 4; AK, 2;

ID, 2; NJ, 1

77
Chlorophyllum molybdites 4 CO, 2; NV, 2 131
Agaricus xanthodermus complex 3 CO 6
Amanita pantherina 31 CO 95
Amanita virosa 22 MN 21
Agaricus brunnescens cultivated 1 ID 0
Amanita flavorubescens 1 NY 0
Amanita vaginata 1 ND 1
Calvatia gigantea 1 NY 1
Cantharellus cibarius 1 OR 10
Cantharellus subalbidus 1 OR 0
Gomphus floccosus 1 CO 1
Leccinum atrostipitatum 1 AK 0
Lepiota rachodes 1 CO 11
Leucoagaricus naucinus 1 NJ 6
Morchella elata 1 OR 5
Morchella esculenta 1 ID 16
Panaeolus foenisecii 1 NJ 16
Phallus impudicus 1 CO 2
Pholiota kodiakensis 1 AK 1
Pluteus cervinus 1 NJ 0
Psilocybe cubensis 1 CO 7
Scleroderma cepa 1 NJ 4
    1All cases in dogs
2One case, dog

    In addition there were 10 cases where the species identification was uncertain; 2, limited to genus; 11 where the species was unknown; 2 involving mixed species. Reasons for incomplete or absent identifications include uncertainty in field("eyeball") inspection; poor condition of specimen; incomplete or absent information, e.g. in a telephone consultation; failure to get mycological advice. Cases where identifications were possible but uncertain included: Agaricus xanthodermus complex, 3; Amanita muscaria or pantherina, 2 dogs and 1 cat; Amanita gemmata or crenulata, 1; Gyromitra sp. "brain", 1; Ramaria near aurea, 2. Two cases of Psilocybe were identified to genus; 11, including 1 dog, species unknown. Two cases were reported with mixed species; 1, Hericium ramosum and Dentinum umbilicatum; 1 Russula spp. and unknown species. Symptoms are not reported with the species for these latter cases.

Misidentifications

    Incorrect identifications of mushroom were cited in 5 cases as follows: Amanita muscaria was believed to be a puffball, 2 cases; Agaricus xanthoderma complex to be Agaricus campestris or other edible Agaricus, 2 cases; Gomphus floccosus, to be Cantharellus cibarius, 1 case.

Mushrooms and Their Symptoms

  Amanita muscaria, 9 cases: 2 infants, asymptomatic, prompt treatment with ipecac; 2 teenagers and 3 adults used raw for recreation- muscle spasm, 3/5; mydriasis, 2/5; ataxia, 2/5; hallucination, 2/5; grand mal seizure, deep sleep; visual disturbance, nausea, vomiting, dyspnea, 1/5; 1 child and 1 adult ate cooked as misidentified puffball; lethargic, hallucination, drunk-feeling, altered mental state, dizzy, intestinal cramps, vomiting.

Chlorophyllum molybdites, 4 cases: 2 children, ate raw; vomiting, 2/2; 2 adults ate cooked for food,; diarrhea, 2/2;
vomiting, 2/2.

Agaricus xanthodermus complex: 3 adults ate cooked for food, 1 with alcohol: malaise, 2/3; vomiting, 2/3.

Amanita pantherina 3 dogs: disoriented, 3/3; lethargic, 3/3; staggering, 2/3; whining, 2/3; panting, 2/3; agitated, 2/3; muscle pain, 2/3; muscle spasm, 1/3; weakness, 1/3.

Amanita virosa 2 cases: 1 child, 8 years old and developmentally delayed ate mushroom in his yard. Vomiting and drowsiness occurred after 6 hours. His tratment included intravenous fluids, penicillin and charcoal. A puppy also ate a mushroom from the yard and vomited followed by hypoglycemia, coagulopathy, liver failure and death.

        The following species were associated with single cases in 1998.

Amanita vaginata: 1 new case and 1 previous. In the recent case an adult male ate 2 or 3 caps and 1 stipe raw. After 4 hours he developed chills, diarrhea, disorientation, drowsiness, intestinal cramps, nausea, sweating, weakness, bloody stool, anemia. A Meixner test was negative for amanitin. Treatment includes gastric lavage, charcoal, intrvenous fluids, and hemoperfusion. In the earlier case an adult male had eaten the mushroom cooked and in 4.5 hours experienced dizziness, nausea, and out-of-body feeling; eaten previously without ill effect.

Calvatia gigantea: 1 new case and 1 previous. Both cases involved adults who had eaten the species before without ill effect. In the recent case the mushroom was starting to brown and was eaten raw, and alcohol was drunk. Drowsiness and vomiting followed in 8-10 hours. The prior case appeared to be an allergic reaction, with rash, flushing and a burning sensation around the mouth.

Cantharellus cibarius: 1 new case and 10 previous. All ate the mushrooms cooked for food, the new case and 1 other with alcohol. The new case suffered vomiting and the prior cases various gastrointestinal symptoms but some of the latter also experienced numbness, pain or edema.

Gomphus floccosus: 1 new case and 1 previous. Both experienced diarrhea and the new case severe intestinal cramps.

Lepiota rachodes: 1 new case and 11 previous. All had gastrointestinal symptoms except 1 previous case, allergy.

Leucoagaricus naucinus: 1 new case (child) and 6 previous (4 children). The new case was asymptomatic, possibly due to prompt treatment with ipecac, but all previous cases had gastrointestinal effects.

Morchella elata: 1 new case, vomiting; and 5 previous, also and more extensive gastrointestinal symptoms.

Morchella esculenta: 1 new case ate a small amount raw and a few cooked, and with alcohol; intestinal cramps and vomiting followed in 1 hour. Among 16 previous cases, 1 ingesting raw specimens suffered explosive diarrhea; others, eating cooked mushrooms, 4 with alcohol, experienced various gastrointestinal symptoms.

Panaeolus foenisecii: 1 new case; a child, asymptomatic treated with ipecac. Sixteen previous cases: 12 in children, 3 asymptomatic, 9 with various central nervous system effects; 3 adults with nausea and dizziness, 1 adult with contact allergic reaction.

Phallus impudicus: 1 new case, adult with contact hypersensitivity; 2 prior cases, both with gastrointestinal symptoms.

Pholiota kodakensis: 1 new report of possible ingestion by asymptomatic child; 1 previous report of adult with gastrointestinal effects after cooked mushrooms.

Psilocybe cubensis: 1 new and 7 previous cases, all in adults, taken for recreation with inimical, central effects.

Scleroderma cepa: 1 new and 4 previous cases. The new case was a child, asymptomatic and treated with ipecac. The previous cases involved 2 child and 2 adults, all eating raw mushrooms with gastrointestinal effects.

    For mushroom species involving a single case, the associated symptoms, particularly gastrointestinal, should be regarded with caution. It may be a "bum rap" for the mushroom. The consumption of a wild mushroom, particularly if one has participated in its collection, may be a memorable event and unpleasant sequelae associated with the mushroom rather than other possible causes such as prior bacterial or chemical contamination of the specimen; concurrent infection of the patient, e.g "stomach flu"; improper storage or cooking. Each of the following species was associated with a single case in the 1998 series and reported for the first time to the Registry.

Agaricus brunnescens cultivated: 6 hours after eating purchased commercial mushrooms that "seemed old and moldy" patient developed chills, sweating fever, pallor and vomiting. Deterioration of the mushrooms, rather than toxicity is a reasonable conclusion.

Amanita flavorubescens: eaten raw by child; vomiting, onset 15 hours.

Cantharellus subalbidus: chills and vomiting; eaten by 2, only 1 ill.

Leccinum atrostipitatium: eaten raw, alcohol involved; nausea, vomiting and diarrhea in 1.5 to 2 hours.

Pleuteus cervinus: eaten raw by child; treated with ipecac and asymptomatic.

Discussion

    "Our findings indicate that common surveillance measures of poisoning and drug overdose may systematically undercount morbidity." (Blanc, P.D., 1993). This is particularly true with the North American Mushroom Poisoning Case Registry. Reporting to the Registry is voluntary, and the utility of the data is vulnerable to the participation and distribution of volunteers. The mycologically naïve among the public and smaller-scale medical care providers, confronted with mushroom poisoning, are most apt to consult the nearest poison center. The United States poison centers' data for 1998 are not available as of this writing, but the Toxic Exposure Surveillance System data for 1997 include reports from all but 6 states (Litovitz, T.L et al, 1998). Ten thousand four hundred seventy seven 1977 TESS reports involved mushrooms (0.75% of the 1,399, 160 nonpharmaceutical exposures), but with 87% of the mushrooms unidentified. More rapport between local poison centers/emergency rooms and local mycologists, professional and amateur, would reduce that level of ignorance, be mutually beneficial and provide opportunities for more reports to the Registry

    Mycophagy is not limited to mushroom club members nor to mycologists and there should be efforts to increase awareness of and reporting to the Registry not only within organized mycology but also the medical establishment and all engaged in outdoor activities who might experience misadventures with mushroom. The following recommendations should not only benefit the Mushroom Poisoning Case Registry but also supplement NAMA's mission to promote, pursue, and advance the science of mycology.

Literature Cited

Blanc, PD et al. 1993. Surveillance of poisoning and drug overdose through hospital discharge coding, poison control center reporting, and the Drug Overdose Warning Network. Am. J. Emerg. Med. 11:14-9

Litovitz, TL et al. 1998. 1997 annual report of the American Association of Poison Control Centers Toxic Exposure Surveillance System. Am. J. Emerg. Med. 16:443-97

* * * * *

Back to MPCR reports.

Back to MPCR home page